I like the winter Olympics better than the summer games, and apropos this . . .
Yesterday I was looking at the medal counts for the Sochi Olympics and it is interesting how things get reported. The Washington Post is reporting the raw medal count which puts the US in third place with 4 gold, 4 silver & 8 bronze for a total of 16. This system, which puts the Swiss, with five gold medals, in eighth place, is ludicrous.
Netherlands 5+5+7=17
Russia 4+7+5=16
USA 4+4+8=16
Norway 5+3+6=14
Canada 4+6+4=14
Germany 7+3+2=12
Sweden 2+5+2=9
Switzerland 5+1+1=7
But that isn’t the way the Olympics are generally looked at. Most of the time it is the gold medal count which determines who’s on first. That changes the standings of the top eight, vaulting the Swiss into a three-way tie for second, putting the USA into a three-way tie for third, and looking like this:
Germany 7+3+2=12
Netherlands 5+5+7=17
Norway 5+3+6=14
Switzerland 5+1+1=7
Russia 4+7+5=16
USA 4+4+8=16
Canada 4+6+4=14
Sweden 2+5+2=9
Now, if we stick to the idea that having more gold medals means more, it follows logically that more silver should also mean more and that premise already appears in the Post where Russia stands one place above the USA. Using the gold + silver count the standings change once more and the USA falls to seventh spot:
Germany 7+3+2=12
Netherlands 5+5+7=17
Norway 5+3+6=14
Switzerland 5+1+1=7
Russia 4+7+5=16
Canada 4+6+4=14
USA 4+4+8=16
Sweden 2+5+2=9
But if you take those figures and weight the medals as gold = 3 pts, silver = 2 & bronze = 1 the standings change again as Russia leaps ahead of Germany and the USA falls into a tie for fourth place where it could be argued whether the total count or the silver count determines who gets to be on top:
Netherlands 5+5+7=17 (15+10+7=32 pts)
Russia 4+7+5=16 (12+14+5=31)
Germany 7+3+2=12 (21+6+2=29 pts)
Canada 4+6+4=14 (12+12+4=28 pts)
USA 4+4+8=16 (12+8+8=28 pts)
Norway 5+3+6=14 (15+6+6=27 pts)
Switzerland 5+1+1=7 (15+2+1=18 pts)
Sweden 2+5+2=9 (4+10+2=16 pts)
What matters most: gold count, gold/silver count, total medal count or total points count? It seems to me that it is all in the eye of the beholder, and it probably shouldn’t be. Don’t sports have rules?